Brownies, Cookies, and Muffins…Oh My!

We Do More Than Just Cake!

At Bake My Day, Green Bay’s premier cake and cupcake bakery, you’ll find a wide array of baked goods to satisfy your sweet tooth’s every desire.


Made-from-scratch cookies use only the finest quality ingredients and are baked fresh daily. Peanut butter, chocolate chip, molasses, sugar, double chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, oatmeal cranberry, and seasonal cutouts. Take just one bite, and you’d swear you were at Grandma’s house.

“The Best Brownies in Town”

It’s what customers say! These chocolaty brownies put any chocolate craving to rest whether you’re in the mood for plain chocolate topped with rich, fudge icing or peanut butter, mint, cream cheese, turtle, or German chocolate. With varying levels of sweeteners it tastes so good, it’s almost sinful.


Make it a meal and then some with warm and soft, massive muffins in apple cinnamon, lemon poppy seed, strawberry rhubarb, pineapple orange, blueberry, orange cranberry nut, banana nut, and—if you’re daring enough—double chocolate and turtle. Baked fresh daily.

Cinnamon Rolls

The chewy, soft texture will have you smiling in satisfaction with the perfect balance of cinnamon and sugar, alongside a perfectly baked secret recipe dough, topped with creamy white icing and just the right amount of sweetness.


Light and flaky in a variety of your favorite fresh fruit flavors, this pastry will delight and satisfy your taste buds. Made from Bake My Day’s unique puff pastry dough, this turnover is just what you need to start the morning off right.